首页 理论 架构 工程 规划 文档 白皮书 著作 研究 规范 下载 博客 关于 联系 开始使用 →

WSaiOS Demand-Driven Dynamic Semantic Theory: A Theoretical Framework for Semantic Requirement Formation, Structural Knowledge Integration, and Intelligence Evolution

WSaiOS Demand-Driven Dynamic Semantic Theory: A Theoretical Framework for Semantic Requirement Formation, Structural Knowledge Integration, and Intelligence Evolution

Author: Wang She Ping
Email: mr.wangweb@gmail.com

Target Journal: Journal of Experimental & Theoretical Artificial Intelligence

Article Type: Research Article — Theoretical Research

Abstract

Semantic understanding remains a fundamental challenge for artificial intelligence because the meaning required to complete a task is not always fully available in the input, the existing knowledge base, or a predefined semantic model. Conventional approaches often represent semantics through predefined vocabularies, ontologies, knowledge graphs, contextual representations, or task-specific retrieval mechanisms. Although these approaches provide important capabilities, a general theoretical account is still needed to explain how semantic requirements arise from a task, how gaps in existing knowledge become identifiable, and how newly acquired semantic information should be integrated into an evolving knowledge structure.

This paper proposes WSaiOS Demand-Driven Dynamic Semantic Theory, a theoretical framework in which semantic requirements are determined by the relationship between a task and the current state of structured knowledge. Under this framework, semantic understanding is not treated as an isolated operation performed solely on an input expression. Instead, it is understood as a dynamic process in which task requirements are interpreted in relation to existing knowledge, missing or insufficient semantic elements are identified, relevant information is acquired, candidate interpretations are evaluated, and the resulting knowledge structure is revised when sufficient evidence is available. The updated structure may subsequently change the requirements of the task and generate further semantic needs.

The paper defines the principal concepts of demand-driven semantics, semantic insufficiency, dynamic semantic construction, evidence-based semantic revision, and structural knowledge evolution. It presents a conceptual process model and a set of theoretical propositions concerning task dependence, knowledge dependence, semantic revision, structural integration, and feedback. The framework also identifies conditions under which its claims could be empirically examined and distinguished from alternative semantic-processing approaches. The proposed theory is intended to provide a foundation for investigating semantic understanding as a task-dependent and knowledge-structuring process within the broader WSaiOS approach to structural intelligence. The framework is theoretical: its propositions require further operationalisation and empirical evaluation before claims about comparative performance or general intelligence can be established.

Keywords: WSaiOS; demand-driven dynamic semantics; semantic understanding; structured knowledge; knowledge insufficiency; semantic construction; knowledge evolution; structural intelligence

1. Introduction

1.1. The problem of semantic understanding

Artificial intelligence systems process language, symbols, observations, and other forms of information to support tasks such as classification, question answering, decision-making, knowledge acquisition, and problem solving. However, processing an expression does not necessarily establish that a system has identified all the meaning required for a particular task.

A task may refer to an unfamiliar object, an incompletely specified property, an unknown relationship, or a concept whose interpretation depends on knowledge that is not yet available. The same expression may also require different information under different task conditions. Consequently, the semantic requirements of a task cannot always be determined by analysing the expression alone.

Existing research has addressed related problems through knowledge representation, semantic modelling, information retrieval, knowledge graph construction, contextual language processing, and related techniques. Knowledge graphs, for example, support the representation and acquisition of entities and relationships, while information retrieval research has examined how relevance depends on information needs and task context (Borlund, 2003; Ji et al., 2022; Zhong et al., 2024).

These approaches provide important foundations. The theoretical problem addressed in this paper is narrower and more specific: how should a system determine what semantic information it needs, given a particular task and its existing structured knowledge, and how should that need guide the construction and revision of semantics?

The question concerns not only how information is represented or retrieved, but also how semantic requirements arise, how insufficiency is recognised, and how the acquisition of new information changes the structure through which subsequent tasks are understood.

1.2. The WSaiOS perspective

WSaiOS Demand-Driven Dynamic Semantic Theory is developed within the broader WSaiOS approach to structural intelligence.

The framework treats structured knowledge as an organised basis for understanding and application. Semantic information is not considered useful merely because it has been acquired or stored. Its significance depends on whether it can be interpreted in relation to the task, integrated into the relevant knowledge structure, and used to support the intended operation.

From this perspective, semantic understanding should not be modelled exclusively as a transformation from an input expression to an output representation. It should also account for the relationship between the task being performed and the knowledge available to perform it.

This relationship creates the central idea of demand-driven semantics: semantic requirements emerge from the requirements of a task in relation to the current knowledge state.

The term dynamic indicates that semantic requirements and semantic representations may change as information is acquired, evaluated, and incorporated into structured knowledge. It does not imply that every task must acquire external information or that every new item of information must modify the knowledge structure. A system may already possess sufficient knowledge, or newly acquired information may prove irrelevant, redundant, inconsistent, or insufficiently supported.

1.3. Research questions

This paper addresses four research questions:

How can semantic requirements be defined in relation to a task and an existing knowledge structure?

How can semantic insufficiency be represented as a difference between required and available knowledge?

How should information acquisition, interpretation, evaluation, and structural revision be related within a dynamic semantic process?

What theoretical propositions follow from this framework, and how could they be examined empirically?

These questions establish the scope of the paper. The objective is to define a coherent theoretical framework rather than to claim that a complete implementation or experimentally validated intelligent system has already been achieved.

1.4. Contributions

The paper makes five proposed theoretical contributions.

First, it defines semantic requirements in relation to task demands and the current state of structured knowledge.

Second, it introduces semantic insufficiency as a conceptual basis for determining when further semantic acquisition or clarification may be necessary.

Third, it connects information acquisition and interpretation with evidence evaluation and knowledge-structure revision.

Fourth, it treats the updated knowledge state as a potential source of changed requirements, establishing a feedback relationship between task performance and subsequent semantic needs.

Fifth, it formulates theoretical propositions and identifies empirical questions that can be used to examine the framework and compare it with alternative approaches.

These contributions are presented as a proposed theoretical synthesis and framework. Their novelty relative to the complete existing literature remains subject to systematic scholarly verification.

2. Background and Theoretical Positioning

2.1. Knowledge representation and knowledge graphs

Knowledge representation provides methods for expressing information in forms that can support reasoning and computation. Knowledge graphs represent entities and their relationships, while knowledge acquisition methods identify, extract, organise, and refine information for inclusion in a graph or related representation.

Surveys of knowledge graphs have examined representation, acquisition, applications, construction, refinement, and evolution (Ji et al., 2022; Zhong et al., 2024). This literature establishes the importance of structured knowledge and the challenges involved in acquiring and maintaining it.

WSaiOS Demand-Driven Dynamic Semantic Theory is concerned with a related but distinct question. It asks how the need for a particular piece of semantic knowledge is determined by the task and the current knowledge state.

A knowledge graph may contain extensive information while still lacking a relationship required by a particular task. Conversely, a task may be completed using knowledge already available without requiring additional acquisition. The quantity of stored knowledge alone therefore does not determine whether the semantic requirements of a task have been satisfied.

The proposed framework places this task–knowledge relationship at the centre of semantic requirement formation.

2.2. Information needs and relevance

Information retrieval research has long examined the relationship between information needs, retrieved information, and relevance. Relevance is not necessarily an intrinsic property of a document considered independently of a user or task; it may depend on the context in which the information is required (Borlund, 2003).

The demand-driven perspective adopts the general importance of task-related relevance while extending the question to the organisation of semantic knowledge.

Information may be relevant to a task without fully resolving its semantic requirements. For example, a source may mention the required object but omit a critical property, provide an ambiguous relationship, or contradict other evidence. Information acquisition must therefore be distinguished from semantic sufficiency.

In this framework, retrieval is one possible means of addressing an identified knowledge insufficiency. It is not itself equivalent to semantic understanding.

2.3. Dynamic semantic processing

Semantic processing may involve contextual interpretation, disambiguation, entity recognition, relation extraction, and the integration of information from multiple sources. Such operations can contribute to the construction of useful semantic representations.

The proposed theory does not claim that these methods are inherently incompatible with demand-driven semantics. They may serve as implementation mechanisms within the broader process.

The theoretical distinction concerns the organisation of the process: semantic requirements are established in relation to a task and the current knowledge state; acquisition and interpretation are directed by those requirements; and the resulting information is evaluated before any justified revision of the knowledge structure.

This perspective differs from treating semantic processing as a fixed sequence that operates identically regardless of the task and existing knowledge.

2.4. The theoretical gap addressed

The relevant gap is not an absence of prior work on semantic understanding, knowledge acquisition, relevance, or knowledge evolution. Each of these subjects has an established research history.

Rather, this paper proposes that their relationships should be examined through an explicit demand-driven theoretical model. The central concern is the dependency between task requirements, existing structured knowledge, semantic insufficiency, information acquisition, interpretation, evidence evaluation, and subsequent structural revision.

Whether this formulation constitutes a sufficiently distinct theoretical contribution must be established through a more comprehensive comparison with existing work. The present paper defines the framework and its implications as a basis for that examination.

3. Core Concepts of WSaiOS Demand-Driven Dynamic Semantic Theory

3.1. Task

A task is the activity or objective for which a system requires semantic information.

A task may involve identifying an object, determining a relationship, evaluating a condition, comparing alternatives, applying a method, or producing a result. Its semantic requirements depend on what must be established to perform the task adequately.

The task is not reduced to a particular input sentence. An input expression may describe the task, but the task also determines which information is relevant and what constitutes a sufficient result.

3.2. Structured knowledge

Structured knowledge is the currently available organisation of information, including whatever elements, properties, relationships, constraints, and other representational components are supported by the system’s knowledge model.

The theory does not prescribe one universal schema or a fixed set of fields. The form of the knowledge structure depends on the representational requirements of the application.

For a given task, some parts of the knowledge structure may be relevant while others may not be. The effective knowledge state is therefore the knowledge available for addressing the task, together with the relationships required to interpret and use that knowledge.

3.3. Semantic requirements

Semantic requirements are the semantic conditions that must be satisfied for a task to be adequately understood or performed.

These requirements may concern the identification of an object, the meaning of a concept, the value or interpretation of a property, the existence of a relationship, the applicability of a rule, or the evidence necessary to support a conclusion.

Semantic requirements are not assumed to be completely known before processing begins. They may be clarified as the task is interpreted and as the limitations of the current knowledge state become apparent.

3.4. Semantic insufficiency

Semantic insufficiency exists when the available knowledge does not adequately satisfy one or more semantic requirements of the task.

Insufficiency may arise because relevant information is absent, incomplete, ambiguous, inconsistent, outdated, or insufficiently supported. These conditions are conceptually different and should not automatically trigger the same response.

For example, missing information may require acquisition; ambiguity may require disambiguation; inconsistency may require comparison and verification; and weak evidence may require further assessment.

The theory therefore does not equate all knowledge insufficiency with a simple absence of data.

3.5. Demand-driven semantic acquisition

Demand-driven semantic acquisition is the process of seeking or obtaining information in response to an identified semantic requirement or insufficiency.

Potential sources may include existing records, documents, external resources, user clarification, structured databases, or other information channels available to the system.

The theory does not require a specific retrieval technology. It defines the role of acquisition within the semantic process: acquisition should address a recognised need rather than being treated as an end in itself.

3.6. Dynamic semantic construction

Dynamic semantic construction is the process of interpreting and organising acquired information in relation to the task and existing knowledge.

Acquired information may clarify a concept, establish a relationship, revise an interpretation, add a missing element, or reveal that the initial understanding of the task was incomplete.

The resulting semantic representation is therefore dependent on both the information acquired and the context in which that information must be understood.

3.7. Evidence-based semantic revision

Information that appears relevant is not automatically suitable for incorporation into structured knowledge. It may be inaccurate, ambiguous, contradictory, redundant, or unrelated to the requirement being addressed.

Evidence-based semantic revision refers to the evaluation of candidate interpretations and the subsequent decision about whether the relevant semantic representation or knowledge structure should be modified.

A revision may add information, clarify a relationship, replace an unsupported interpretation, preserve conflicting alternatives, or leave the existing structure unchanged when the available evidence is inadequate.

The theory consequently distinguishes candidate semantic construction from justified knowledge revision.

3.8. Knowledge evolution and feedback

When a justified revision changes the available knowledge, subsequent tasks may require different semantic information from that previously required.

A newly established relationship may resolve an earlier insufficiency. It may also reveal an additional question, introduce a new constraint, or change which methods are applicable.

Knowledge evolution is therefore connected to the changing relationship between tasks and structured knowledge. Feedback provides information about whether the updated knowledge adequately supports the intended task and whether further clarification or revision is needed.

This feedback relationship is a theoretical feature of the framework. Its practical realisation depends on the capabilities and design of a particular implementation.

4. Formal Model

4.1. Notation

Let the following symbols denote the principal components of the framework:

(T): the task under consideration.

(K_t): the structured knowledge available at stage (t).

(R(T,K_t)): the semantic requirements identified for task (T) in relation to (K_t).

(S(T,K_t)): the requirements adequately satisfied by the available knowledge.

(G(T,K_t)): the remaining semantic insufficiency.

(I_t): information acquired to address the identified insufficiency.

(C_t): candidate semantic interpretations constructed from the acquired information and existing knowledge.

(V_t): the evaluation of candidate interpretations and supporting evidence.

(D_t): the current semantic representation relevant to the task.

(F_t): feedback concerning the adequacy of the updated knowledge for the task.

These symbols describe a conceptual model. They do not prescribe a fixed database schema, a particular data structure, or a fully specified executable algorithm.

4.2. Identifying semantic insufficiency

The semantic requirements of a task are represented as:

[
R_t = R(T,K_t)
]

The subset of those requirements adequately satisfied by the current knowledge is:

[
S_t = S(T,K_t)
]

The remaining insufficiency is defined conceptually as:

[
G_t = R_t \setminus S_t
]

This set-difference expression assumes that requirements can be represented in a form that permits satisfaction to be assessed. In practical systems, requirements may be graded, uncertain, interdependent, or only partially satisfied. In those cases, the set representation would need to be extended to express degrees of satisfaction, confidence, or dependency.

The important theoretical point is that the insufficiency is defined relative to both the task and the current knowledge state. It is not simply the set of all information that the system does not possess.

4.3. Demand-driven acquisition

When the identified insufficiency is non-empty and further information is justified, the system may acquire information directed towards the unresolved requirements:

[
I_t = \operatorname{Acquire}(G_t)
]

The acquisition operation is conditional. If the existing knowledge is sufficient, no further acquisition is required by the theory. If the insufficiency cannot be resolved using available sources, the system may retain the unresolved status rather than assume that a satisfactory answer has been found.

Acquisition may return incomplete or conflicting information. Consequently, the output of acquisition is a set or collection of candidate information, not an automatic guarantee of semantic correctness.

4.4. Constructing candidate semantics

Candidate semantic interpretations are formed in relation to the task, acquired information, and existing knowledge:

[
C_t =
\operatorname{Interpret}(I_t,T,K_t)
]

The interpretation operation may include identifying concepts, resolving references, determining relationships, comparing alternative meanings, and establishing how the acquired information relates to the current knowledge structure.

The expression does not assume that interpretation is always deterministic or that only one candidate interpretation exists. A system may retain several alternatives when the evidence does not justify selecting a single interpretation.

4.5. Evaluating candidate interpretations

Candidate interpretations are evaluated against the available evidence and the semantic requirements of the task:

[
V_t =
\operatorname{Assess}(C_t,I_t,T,K_t)
]

Evaluation may consider relevance to the task, consistency with existing knowledge, source reliability, evidential support, ambiguity, and the consequences of incorporating the candidate interpretation.

The theory does not prescribe a universal scoring function or a single numerical threshold. Different applications may require different evaluation criteria, and some criteria may be qualitative rather than numerical.

The formal requirement is that candidate construction and justified revision remain conceptually distinct.

4.6. Revising semantic representations

The current semantic representation may be revised in response to the evaluated candidates:

[
D_{t+1} =
\operatorname{Revise}(D_t,C_t,V_t)
]

Revision is conditional on the evaluation outcome. If the evidence is insufficient, the representation may remain unchanged or preserve unresolved alternatives. If the evidence supports a correction or addition, the relevant semantic representation may be modified.

The resulting knowledge state is represented as:

[
K_{t+1} =
\operatorname{Update}(K_t,D_{t+1})
]

The update operation must respect the representational rules and integrity conditions of the application. The equation does not imply that every candidate must be added to the knowledge base or that the entire knowledge structure must be rebuilt after every task.

4.7. Feedback and changing requirements

The adequacy of the updated knowledge for the task may be assessed through feedback:

[
F_t =
\operatorname{Feedback}(T,K_{t+1})
]

The feedback may indicate that the task has been adequately supported, that an uncertainty remains, or that an additional semantic requirement has emerged.

The requirements for the next stage can therefore be reconsidered:

[
R_{t+1} =
\operatorname{ReviseRequirements}(T,K_{t+1},F_t)
]

This expression captures the dynamic relationship between semantic requirements and the evolving knowledge state. It does not mean that requirements must change at every iteration. If the task and its semantic requirements remain adequately addressed, the process may terminate.

4.8. Overall process

The model can be summarised as the following conceptual cycle:

[
\begin{aligned}
&\text{Task and Current Knowledge}\
&\quad\downarrow\
&\text{Semantic Requirement Identification}\
&\quad\downarrow\
&\text{Insufficiency Assessment}\
&\quad\downarrow\
&\text{Information Acquisition, if Needed}\
&\quad\downarrow\
&\text{Semantic Interpretation}\
&\quad\downarrow\
&\text{Evidence Evaluation}\
&\quad\downarrow\
&\text{Knowledge-Structure Revision, if Justified}\
&\quad\downarrow\
&\text{Task Feedback and Requirement Reassessment}
\end{aligned}
]

The process is conditional rather than an obligatory linear pipeline. A task may be resolved using existing knowledge; a clarification request may be needed before acquisition; conflicting evidence may require further investigation; or the process may stop when available information cannot support a reliable conclusion.

The model’s central commitment is the dependency between task requirements, existing knowledge, semantic insufficiency, and justified structural revision.

5. Theoretical Propositions

The following propositions express claims implied by the proposed framework. They are not presented as experimentally established findings.

Proposition 1: Semantic requirements are task-dependent

For a given knowledge state, different tasks may generate different semantic requirements.

Formally, for tasks (T_1) and (T_2), it is possible that:

[
R(T_1,K_t) \ne R(T_2,K_t)
]

even when the available knowledge state is unchanged.

Implication. A system should not assume that one universal semantic requirement set is sufficient for every task. The requirements must be interpreted in relation to the activity being performed.

Testable question. When task objectives change while the knowledge state remains constant, do the identified semantic requirements change in a way that improves task adequacy?

Proposition 2: Semantic insufficiency depends on the current knowledge state

For a fixed task, the semantic insufficiency may change when the available knowledge changes.

[
G(T,K_t) \ne G(T,K_{t+1})
]

is possible when the updated knowledge resolves or introduces relevant requirements.

Implication. Semantic insufficiency should be reassessed when relevant knowledge is added, corrected, or reinterpreted.

Testable question. Does requirement assessment based on the current knowledge state identify unresolved semantic needs more accurately than assessment based solely on the initial input?

Proposition 3: Information acquisition is conditionally required

Additional acquisition is not inherently necessary for every semantic task. Its theoretical justification depends on whether relevant requirements remain insufficiently satisfied and whether further information may reasonably address them.

Implication. A demand-driven system should distinguish tasks that can be resolved using existing knowledge from tasks that require further information.

Testable question. Compared with an approach that retrieves information without explicitly assessing semantic insufficiency, does a requirement-conditioned acquisition strategy reduce unnecessary retrieval while preserving task adequacy?

Proposition 4: Acquisition alone does not establish semantic sufficiency

The presence of newly acquired information does not guarantee that the semantic requirements of a task have been satisfied.

Implication. Acquisition must be followed by interpretation and evaluation when the task requires a supported semantic conclusion.

Testable question. How frequently do retrieved items fail to resolve the identified requirement because they are incomplete, ambiguous, contradictory, or insufficiently reliable?

Proposition 5: Knowledge revision should be conditional on evaluation

A candidate interpretation should not automatically become established knowledge merely because it has been generated or retrieved.

Implication. A semantic system should preserve the distinction between candidate interpretations and accepted or otherwise qualified knowledge.

Testable question. Does explicit evidence evaluation reduce unsupported structural changes compared with automatic incorporation of candidate information?

Proposition 6: Structural knowledge revision can change subsequent semantic requirements

When a justified update changes the knowledge relevant to a task, the semantic requirements of subsequent processing may also change.

Implication. The semantic process should permit requirements to be reconsidered after knowledge revision rather than treating the initial requirements as permanently fixed.

Testable question. Can feedback from revised knowledge identify additional requirements or eliminate previously unresolved ones in a manner that improves subsequent task performance?

Proposition 7: Dynamic semantic processing requires a termination condition

A demand-driven process cannot assume that every semantic insufficiency can be resolved. It therefore requires a way to recognise sufficient task support, an unresolved limitation, or a justified stopping point.

Implication. An implementation should distinguish successful resolution from unresolved uncertainty and unavailable evidence.

Testable question. Which termination criteria provide an appropriate balance between task adequacy, unresolved uncertainty, acquisition cost, and processing time for a given application?

6. Relationship to WSaiOS Structural Intelligence

6.1. Semantic understanding within a structural approach

WSaiOS Demand-Driven Dynamic Semantic Theory is intended to form part of the broader WSaiOS approach to structural intelligence.

Within this perspective, structured knowledge provides an organised basis for identifying objects, properties, relationships, constraints, and conditions relevant to a task. Semantic understanding concerns how information acquires meaning within that structure and how missing or inadequate meaning can be identified and addressed.

The dynamic semantic framework therefore addresses a specific theoretical problem within the larger structural approach: how semantic requirements arise and how semantic knowledge can be acquired, interpreted, evaluated, and revised in response to those requirements.

The theory does not claim that semantic processing alone constitutes the entirety of structural intelligence. Nor does it imply that semantic acquisition automatically produces reasoning, decision-making, execution, or learning capabilities. Those capabilities require their own definitions and mechanisms within a complete system.

6.2. Semantic requirements and structural relationships

A semantic requirement may concern more than the identification of an isolated concept. It may concern how a concept relates to other elements in the knowledge structure and whether that relationship supports the task.

For example, identifying an object may not be sufficient when the task depends on the object’s properties, its relationship to another object, or the conditions under which a method can be applied.

In such cases, the semantic requirement concerns the information needed to establish or evaluate a structural relationship. Newly acquired information is useful only insofar as it helps address that requirement and can be interpreted within the relevant knowledge representation.

This illustrates why the theory focuses on the relationship between requirements and structured knowledge rather than treating the acquisition of textual information as the final objective.

6.3. From semantic acquisition to knowledge application

A completed semantic update may provide a more adequate knowledge basis for subsequent operations. Whether those operations can actually be performed depends on the capabilities of the system using the knowledge.

The theoretical relationship can be expressed as:

[
\text{Task}
\rightarrow
\text{Semantic Requirements}
\rightarrow
\text{Knowledge Assessment}
\rightarrow
\text{Semantic Construction}
\rightarrow
\text{Structural Revision}
\rightarrow
\text{Subsequent Application}
]

This sequence is conceptual. It does not establish that all downstream capabilities have already been implemented in a WSaiOS system.

6.4. Knowledge evolution

The framework connects dynamic semantics with knowledge evolution by allowing updated knowledge to influence subsequent semantic requirements.

This relationship is more specific than simply accumulating information over time. Accumulation may increase the volume of stored information without resolving the semantic needs of a task. Under the proposed framework, the relevant concern is whether an update changes the knowledge available for understanding and performing subsequent tasks.

A complete account of knowledge evolution would additionally need to specify how revisions are represented, how conflicting information is managed, how earlier states are preserved where necessary, and how the effects of an update are evaluated. These issues are implementation and research questions arising from the theory rather than capabilities assumed to be solved by the present formal model.

7. Distinction from Related Approaches

7.1. Relation to knowledge graphs

Knowledge graphs provide representations of entities and relationships and support a range of knowledge acquisition and reasoning tasks (Ji et al., 2022; Zhong et al., 2024).

The proposed theory does not reject graph-based representations. A knowledge graph could serve as the structured knowledge state (K_t) in an implementation.

The distinction lies in the question being modelled. Knowledge graph construction primarily concerns how graph knowledge is represented, acquired, or refined. WSaiOS Demand-Driven Dynamic Semantic Theory focuses on how task-dependent semantic requirements are identified in relation to the current knowledge state and how those requirements guide further semantic construction and revision.

This is a distinction in theoretical emphasis, not a claim that existing knowledge graph research never addresses task dependence or dynamic updates.

7.2. Relation to information retrieval

Information retrieval methods locate information that may satisfy an information need. Relevance research recognises the importance of the relationship between information and the task or user need (Borlund, 2003).

The proposed framework can use information retrieval as an acquisition mechanism. Its theoretical emphasis extends to the relationship between retrieved information, semantic insufficiency, interpretation, evidence evaluation, and structural revision.

A retrieved result is therefore an input to semantic processing rather than proof that the task’s requirements have been satisfied.

7.3. Relation to contextual semantic processing

Contextual semantic processing uses surrounding information and other contextual signals to interpret expressions. Such mechanisms may contribute to the interpretation operation in the proposed model.

The framework does not assume that contextual interpretation is unnecessary or inadequate in itself. Instead, it distinguishes contextual interpretation from the broader question of how the system determines which semantic information the task requires and how the interpretation should affect structured knowledge.

Whether this distinction produces measurable advantages must be evaluated empirically.

7.4. Relation to retrieval-augmented language systems

A system that retrieves external information and supplies it to a language model can improve access to relevant information. However, retrieval alone does not necessarily establish that a system has explicitly represented the task’s semantic requirements, assessed the insufficiency of its structured knowledge, or controlled structural revision through an independently specified evaluation process.

The proposed theory is not defined by the use or rejection of any particular language model. A language model, retrieval component, or information extraction mechanism could be used to implement individual operations.

The theoretical question is whether the complete process is organised around the dependency between task requirements, current knowledge, semantic insufficiency, evidence evaluation, and knowledge revision.

A rigorous comparison must therefore compare operational definitions and system behaviour rather than assume that every retrieval-augmented system follows the same process.

7.5. Scope of the claimed distinction

The distinctions described above establish the intended positioning of the framework. They do not demonstrate that no existing theory contains equivalent or closely related ideas.

Establishing the extent of originality requires a systematic literature review that examines semantic understanding, information needs, knowledge acquisition, adaptive knowledge representation, active information acquisition, and related theoretical work.

The proposed contribution should be judged by the specificity of its definitions, the logical relationship among its components, the explanatory value of its propositions, and the results of direct comparison with existing approaches.

8. Evaluation and Falsifiability

8.1. Purpose of evaluation

A theoretical framework should provide claims that can be examined rather than remaining solely a conceptual description.

The propositions in this paper suggest several possible evaluation questions. The objective of such evaluation would be to determine whether explicitly representing task-dependent semantic requirements and knowledge insufficiency produces observable differences in semantic processing.

No experiment, benchmark result, or comparative performance improvement is claimed in this paper.

8.2. Comparing task-dependent and task-independent requirement assessment

One evaluation could compare two systems operating on the same tasks and initial knowledge.

The first system would identify semantic requirements in relation to both the task and the available knowledge. The second would use a requirement specification that does not adapt to the current knowledge state.

The comparison could examine whether the systems differ in their identification of missing information, the relevance of acquired information, and their ability to complete the task under equivalent conditions.

The evaluation would require explicit definitions of task success, requirement satisfaction, and the baseline system’s behaviour.

8.3. Comparing acquisition strategies

A second evaluation could compare requirement-conditioned acquisition with an acquisition strategy that retrieves information without first explicitly assessing semantic insufficiency.

Potential measures include retrieval volume, the proportion of acquired information relevant to unresolved requirements, the frequency of unresolved requirements after acquisition, and the resources needed to complete the task.

The expected direction of any difference should not be assumed in advance. A requirement-conditioned strategy might reduce unnecessary retrieval in some settings, but its effectiveness would depend on the accuracy of requirement identification and the costs of that assessment.

8.4. Evaluating evidence-based revision

A third evaluation could examine whether separating candidate interpretation from accepted knowledge reduces unsupported updates.

The comparison could measure the frequency of incorrect structural additions, the handling of conflicting sources, the preservation of unresolved uncertainty, and the ability to correct earlier interpretations when stronger evidence becomes available.

The evaluation would need a defined reference standard for determining whether a particular update is supported.

8.5. Evaluating feedback and requirement revision

A fourth evaluation could investigate whether feedback from updated knowledge helps identify changed or newly exposed semantic requirements.

The experiment would need tasks in which relevant knowledge changes over time. It could examine whether subsequent requirement assessments reflect the changes and whether those assessments affect task outcomes.

A failure to produce reliable changes in requirement identification, or a lack of improvement in task adequacy under suitable controlled conditions, would limit the empirical support for the corresponding proposition.

8.6. Conditions for meaningful testing

A credible evaluation would require:

Explicit operational definitions of tasks, semantic requirements, and knowledge insufficiency.

A documented representation of the initial and updated knowledge states.

Baselines that isolate the effects of requirement assessment, acquisition, evaluation, and revision.

Reproducible task data and evaluation criteria.

Reporting of failures, unresolved cases, and contradictory evidence.

Appropriate treatment of uncertainty and differences among application domains.

These requirements are not claimed to have been satisfied by an existing experiment. They specify what would be needed to evaluate the theory systematically.

9. Discussion

9.1. Theoretical significance

The proposed framework places the relationship between task requirements and structured knowledge at the centre of dynamic semantic processing.

Its primary claim is that semantic requirements should be understood relative to what a task requires and what the current knowledge state can adequately support. This relationship provides a conceptual basis for identifying insufficiency and determining whether further information or clarification is needed.

The framework also distinguishes acquiring information from establishing its meaning and from deciding whether it should modify structured knowledge. This separation helps clarify several logically different operations that can otherwise be conflated in descriptions of semantic processing.

Finally, the framework allows knowledge revision to influence subsequent requirements. Semantic processing is therefore modelled as potentially iterative rather than necessarily terminating after a single interpretation or retrieval operation.

9.2. Semantic sufficiency is task-relative

The framework does not define a universal threshold at which a knowledge base becomes semantically complete.

A knowledge state may be sufficient for one task and insufficient for another. The same task may also become insufficiently supported when its conditions, constraints, or required level of confidence change.

Semantic sufficiency must therefore be assessed in relation to an explicit task and an appropriate criterion for task adequacy.

This does not mean that every application must use a numerical sufficiency score. Some tasks may permit rule-based criteria, human verification, or other forms of assessment. The appropriate operational definition remains an empirical and application-specific question.

9.3. The importance of unresolved uncertainty

A demand-driven framework must allow the possibility that a requirement remains unresolved.

External sources may be unavailable, conflicting, unreliable, or unable to supply the required information. A system that always forces a single interpretation risks converting insufficient evidence into an unsupported conclusion.

The proposed distinction between candidate interpretation and evaluated revision allows unresolved uncertainty to remain explicit. The exact representation of uncertainty, however, is not fully specified by the current model and requires further development.

9.4. The relationship between theory and implementation

The formal model is intended to clarify dependencies among conceptual components. It is not yet a complete algorithm.

An implementation would need to define how tasks are represented, how requirements are identified, how insufficiency is assessed, how information is acquired, how interpretations are evaluated, and how updates are applied to the knowledge structure.

Different implementations may use different data structures and algorithms while following the same conceptual dependency. Conversely, a system that merely retrieves information or updates a knowledge base does not necessarily implement the full theory.

This distinction is important when evaluating whether an implementation genuinely instantiates the proposed framework.

9.5. Limitations

The paper has several limitations.

First, the formalisation remains conceptual. The operations are defined by their theoretical roles rather than by complete computational procedures.

Second, the propositions have not been empirically validated in this paper. No performance advantage, generality, or practical effectiveness is established.

Third, the relationship between the framework and the full existing literature has not yet been exhaustively established. A more comprehensive review may identify related theories or mechanisms that require more precise differentiation.

Fourth, the framework does not yet provide a complete treatment of uncertainty, contradictory evidence, source reliability, requirement dependencies, or termination criteria.

Fifth, the model does not demonstrate that a system implementing its semantic process will necessarily exhibit general intelligence, autonomous reasoning, or reliable decision-making. Such claims would require separate definitions and evidence.

These limitations define the current scope of the contribution and the work needed to strengthen it.

10. Conclusion

This paper has proposed WSaiOS Demand-Driven Dynamic Semantic Theory as a theoretical framework for understanding how semantic requirements arise from the relationship between a task and the current state of structured knowledge.

The framework defines semantic insufficiency as a task-relative condition and connects it to conditional information acquisition, semantic interpretation, evidence evaluation, knowledge-structure revision, and feedback. It further proposes that the updated knowledge state may change the semantic requirements of subsequent processing.

The central theoretical position is that semantic understanding should be examined not only as the interpretation of an input, but also as a process governed by task requirements and the adequacy of the available knowledge structure.

The formal model and theoretical propositions provide a basis for further analysis. Their value depends on whether they can be defined operationally, distinguished from existing approaches, and supported through reproducible empirical evaluation.

Within the broader WSaiOS approach to structural intelligence, the proposed theory is intended to address the semantic relationship between task demands and structured knowledge. Its contribution should ultimately be assessed through the precision of its theoretical definitions, its explanatory scope, and the evidence obtained from systematic comparison and testing.

References

Borlund, P. (2003). The concept of relevance in IR. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 54(10), 913–925. https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.10286

Ji, S., Pan, S., Cambria, E., Marttinen, P., & Yu, P. S. (2022). A survey on knowledge graphs: Representation, acquisition, and applications. IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks and Learning Systems, 33(2), 494–514. https://doi.org/10.1109/TNNLS.2021.3070843

Zhong, Z., et al. (2024). A comprehensive survey on automatic knowledge graph construction. ACM Computing Surveys, 56(4), Article 94, 1–62. https://doi.org/10.1145/3618295

Declarations

Author: Wang She Ping

Corresponding author email: mr.wangweb@gmail.com

Author affiliation: Not provided.

Funding: To be completed by the author, as applicable.

Conflict of interest: To be confirmed by the author.

Data availability: No new empirical dataset is reported in this theoretical paper.

Ethics approval: Not applicable to the theoretical analysis presented in this manuscript.

Generative AI declaration: To be completed in accordance with the target journal’s current disclosure policy and the author’s circumstances.

Acknowledgements: None specified.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

客服咨询
● 欢迎咨询与合作
您好!欢迎咨询。 我可以帮助您了解人工智能技术研发、智能软件系统开发、网站建设、搜索优化及项目定制等相关信息。 请问有什么可以帮您?
免费申请
请填写以下信息,方便我们进一步沟通。
欢迎咨询 AI 系统开发、网站建设、搜索优化、项目定制合作
电话:15089196448
邮箱:1602401899@qq.com
地址:陕西省渭南市
服务时间:周一至周五 09:00 - 18:00 | 7×24小时技术值守